I think Dan Meyer is onto YAGT (yet-another-great-thing) over at his blog.
Along with creating math movies even an English teacher type loves to watch, a design & presentation centric mindset, and enough sharp on his rhetorical blade to wake folks up when professional laziness sets in, he's now angling towards a deep exploration of CM (classroom management) that is already getting a mad flurry of comment responses.
Check it out for yourself. Really. Go. There. Now.
Or plan to stay after school and have me call your parents.
I left the following comment (which I gotta believe Dan is very close to erasing for sheer length alone) in response, which is cross-posted for your I-got-nothing-better-to-do convenience below:
***
Your post brought me back to a moment one month into my 2nd student
teaching assignment. Everything I accidentally learned in one 5-minute
moment — while lying on my back underneath a fallen chair-desk as my
students looked on — continues to be the center of my classroom
management style today, more than 15 years later.
For those who lack interest in reading the rest, suffice it to say
that it comes down to the following very impressive and much-researched
formula I’m trying to copyright and cash-in:
TMEM&LLF + DS + TLA + SSLA + H (nP, nGMAStSF) = RBH(nP), which in turn leads to ECM
TMEM&LLF: Teacher makes an epic mistake, looks like a fool, in front of his/her students
DS: Deep silence across the classroom (although you can feel the snickers beginning to grow strength)
TLA: Teacher laughs aloud (at self — the crux)
SSLA: Stunned students finally laugh aloud (strangely following TIF teacher’s lead…)
H (nP, nGMAStSF): Teacher demonstrates ‘humility’ (not ‘power’)
— modeling what most of the kids feel internally themselves most days —
and chooses not to get mad at students to save face as the
‘adult’/expert in room
RBH(nP): A strange layer of ‘respect’ based on humility (not
perfection)suddenly enters the room as teacher manages to both
laugh-at-oneself while simultaneously acknowledging the students as
having a legit reason to laugh, as teacher manages to continue teaching
as if this was the ‘most normal thing in the world to happen to
him/her’…
ECM: Effective Classroom Management
***
My story (that continues to fuel my CM style even today):
Class:
‘$egular’ 9th grade English, Midwest public school,
low/mid socio-economic scale, early 90’s. While there were some real
9th graders in my class (the nervous ones, even more nervous than I
was), most were in their 2nd or 3rd go on this class…and waiting until
they could legally drop out of school and get a ‘real’ job with their
hands.
Topic:
Greek mythology. Something not-so ground-zero to their
real lives. We were color-mapping Ulysses’ sailing adventures as a way
to break out of the text a bit. Most of these kids had never seen a
sailboat; most never would. Greece was a movie to them, maybe;
certainly not a place they’d ever visit. Ulysses’ trip was as vital as
the chemical composition of the lunchroom tray they carried their tater
tots on when they didn’t leap the fence at lunchtime.
Me:
At 23, I was filled with just enough swagger, nerves,
coffee (and cigarettes, since I still smoked to balance out those 3
elements back then) to ‘fake’ my way through most days when my lead
teacher left the room (for 2+ months at one point). I knew very little
about teaching or the subject, to be honest, but I wasn’t gonna let any
of my kiddos know that.
The Moment:
Feeling as if my students and I were actually
‘connecting’ for a change, I sat on the edge of one of the empty
classroom chair-desks to get ‘closer’ to my audience and to make a
final point about the Sirens or Medusa or some dog the main character
left at home before his journey began 10 years earlier. Lots of eye
contact. 15 minutes to go before the class ended. Feeling good.
…
Then suddenly I was up in the air, landing on my back, upside down
looking at the ceiling, that very chair-desk now laying on top of me.
Apparently physics decided to add a little humility to my day.
The room was silent. Dead silent. All eyes looking my way, most
likely on the verge of throwing me off the cliff for the rest of the
year, or at least under a bus…
I looked up. Caught the eye of one of my wrestlers who hated the
class (and probably me). I smiled. Said to him (loud enough for
everyone else in the class to hear), “Josh, If I had been you watching that, I’d be laughing my ass off at this moment.” And I began laughing.
His eyes got wide. Real wide. Then he laughed. A legit you-and-me
kind of laugh. The other kids followed. I continued laughing. As did
they.
And then I kept on teaching, right there while laying on my back,
the chair-desk still laying across my stomach/legs, as if it was part
of my master plan all along. In a minute or so, after I got back onto
my 2 feet, I noticed that most of the class was actually taking notes.
Crazy, that…
…because looking back, I had maybe 30 seconds to create or destroy
my future teaching career….and there was zero middle ground to choose
from and my audience wasn’t gonna throw me a bone if I selected poorly.
…
I figured out 2 key things at that moment that I’ve never forgotten:
1. Most teachers spend too much time trying to validate their
authority or expertise, when both already are givens the moment they
walk in the door. What they fail to do is validate their students in
the process.
2. Kids see teachers fail every day. Rarely, however, do they see
teachers take failure in stride and turn it into something healthy in
the process. Sadly, many teachers feel such embarrassment when they do
fail in front of their kids that they actually take it out on the kids
instead. Silly, that. Most of our students feel failure every second of
their school life — that nature of the game for kids both in and out of the classroom as their identity/ego is in constant flux
— and what they need around them are more adults/teachers that seem to
handle their own ‘human’ experiences with a bit of humor and and
humility.
Otherwise, how will they learn how to do it themselves?
***
So there you have it: my CM.
I fell of a chair-desk as a student teacher. I laughed at myself. In
front of the kids. And allowed them to laugh at me, too…while subtly
taking back control of the classroom in the process. It still works
today. 15 years later. When I’m still making mistakes constantly, but
never taking that out on my kids to save face.
Oh…
…and the fact that I can steamroll each and every one of them in a battle-of-words when they get uppety.
(he smiles)
Image of chair-desk.
Recent Comments